Cream Cheese Mints With a Secret Ingredient You’ll Love

Cream cheese mints are a timeless treat that blend rich, creamy texture with just the right touch of sweetness. Whether you’re planning a wedding, baby shower, holiday gathering, or simply want to fill your candy dish with something homemade, cream cheese mints are easy to prepare and always a crowd favorite.

In this guide, you’ll learn everything from how to make cream cheese mints at home to flavor variations, drying times, and serving suggestions for large events. We’ll also walk through common problems like stickiness or cracking, plus give tips on how many to make per guest. Whether you’re new to candy making or brushing up your skills, this article gives you practical steps for perfect mints every time.

Table of Contents

How to Make Cream Cheese Mints at Home

Easy Cream Cheese Mints Recipe

Making cream cheese mints at home takes only a few ingredients and about 20 minutes of hands-on time. These soft, melt-in-your-mouth candies are ideal for holidays, weddings, and baby showers. You can use different molds or roll and cut them with simple tools.

Here’s a basic recipe you can follow:

Ingredient	Amount
Cream cheese (softened)	8 oz
Butter (optional, for richness)	2 tbsp
Powdered sugar	5 to 6 cups
Peppermint extract	1/2 tsp
Food coloring (optional)	As desired

After mixing everything together, roll into small balls and press into candy molds or flatten with a fork. You can refrigerate them or let them dry at room temperature overnight.

For another sweet, no-bake favorite, try these no-bake peanut butter cookies, perfect for gifting with your mints.

Tips for Smooth Texture and Flavor

Consistency matters in cream cheese mints. If your mixture feels sticky, add more powdered sugar. If it’s dry or crumbly, knead it until it’s smooth. Chill the dough briefly if you’re shaping with molds.

You can switch up the flavor by using almond, lemon, or even raspberry extracts. Match your food coloring to your event theme. If you’re prepping for a party, consider pairing these mints with something soft and colorful like strawberry rhubarb crumble bars.

Hosting brunch or a tea party? These mints also go well with blueberry sour cream scones, bringing a sweet finish to any table.

And if you want a buttery base to complement the mints, check out this orange pound cake recipe—moist and rich with citrus flavor.

Best Ingredients for Cream Cheese Mints

What You Need for a Classic Batch

To make the best cream cheese mints, you need high-quality ingredients that guarantee flavor and smooth texture. Start with full-fat cream cheese—never use low-fat or whipped versions, which can affect consistency.

Always sift your powdered sugar before mixing to avoid lumps and get a silky finish. For the best results, combine your cream cheese and peppermint extract at room temperature before adding sugar slowly.

Here’s a quick checklist to keep on hand:

• Full-fat cream cheese (block-style)
• Sifted powdered sugar
• Pure peppermint extract (not imitation)
• Gel-based food coloring (optional)
• Cornstarch or extra sugar for rolling/molding

Looking for more ways to use up extra cream cheese? Try this easy cut-out cream cheese sugar cookies recipe, perfect for holiday trays.

Flavor Variations and Coloring Ideas

Classic cream cheese mints are peppermint flavored, but you can easily switch it up for variety. Try almond, vanilla, lemon, or even orange extract for something new. Divide the dough and use different extracts in each portion to create a mix of flavors.

For colors, go with soft pastels for weddings or baby showers. Gel food coloring works best—it’s vibrant and doesn’t water down the mix. Try pink and white for Valentine’s Day, or red and green for Christmas.

Pair these themed mints with something that complements the mood, like chocolate strawberry cake for romantic occasions, or peanut butter pie for a creamy dessert buffet.

Use shaped molds like hearts, flowers, or stars depending on the event. Keep finished mints in an airtight container with parchment between layers for best freshness.

How to Dry Cream Cheese Mints Properly

Drying Time and Setup Techniques

Once your cream cheese mints are shaped, drying them properly helps improve texture and prevents stickiness. The ideal method is air-drying at room temperature. Lay them on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper in a single layer. Avoid stacking or covering them.

Let the mints sit uncovered for 12 to 24 hours, depending on humidity. Turn them halfway through for even drying. If you’re in a rush, refrigerating for a few hours helps firm them faster but doesn’t provide the same finished texture.

If you’re making multiple batches for an event, space is key. Drying racks or tiered trays can be helpful. Want something else to prep ahead? Try these freezer breakfast burritos—they save you time on busy mornings.

Why Drying Impacts Taste and Texture

Drying isn’t just about firmness—it directly affects the way cream cheese mints feel and taste. Undried mints tend to stay tacky and can stick to packaging or melt during display. Well-dried mints develop a smooth outer layer with a creamy, melt-in-your-mouth center.

If your home is especially humid, you can use a dehumidifier or place a small bowl of cornstarch near the drying trays to help absorb excess moisture. Just avoid refrigerating them before they’ve air-dried, as cold storage locks in moisture.

For more ideas that hold up well at room temperature, check out these banana pudding dip and pistachio cake recipes—they’re both delicious and presentation-friendly.

Serving Cream Cheese Mints at Weddings and Events

How Many Mints Per Person for a Wedding

If you’re planning to serve cream cheese mints at a wedding or large event, one of the first questions is quantity. For weddings, 4 to 6 mints per guest is a good estimate, especially if other desserts are being served. For candy buffets or favor bags, aim for 8 to 10 per person.

You can easily scale the recipe depending on your guest list. One batch typically makes about 50 to 60 small mints, depending on the mold size. For a wedding of 100 guests, plan on making 8 to 10 batches ahead of time.

Looking for more ideas to round out your dessert table? Pair your mints with rich, crowd-pleasing options like this chocolate strawberry cake or easy peanut butter pie.

Packaging and Display Ideas

Presentation matters, especially at events like weddings and showers. Use mini cupcake liners to serve your cream cheese mints on trays. You can also package them in small cellophane bags or clear boxes tied with ribbon for take-home favors.

Add a tag with the flavor or event name for a personalized touch. Store them in the fridge until the day of the event, then let them come to room temperature before serving to keep their texture soft and creamy.

For an elegant spring-themed table, pair mints with fruity treats like strawberry shortcake or buttery orange pound cake. These combinations work well for bridal brunches, Easter, and Mother’s Day too.

Cream Cheese vs. Buttermints: What’s the Difference?

3 Simple Ingredients in Traditional Buttermints

Buttermints are often confused with cream cheese mints, but they use slightly different ingredients. The base for buttermints typically includes:

• Butter
• Powdered sugar
• Mint extract (often peppermint or spearmint)

These mints are firmer and less creamy in texture compared to cream cheese mints, which use softened cream cheese for a meltier consistency. Buttermints are more crumbly and can be made ahead in large batches as well.

If you’re more into traditional candy-making, check out these soft hello dolly bars for a buttery alternative with layers of flavor.

Taste, Texture, and Use Comparisons

The major difference lies in taste and mouthfeel. Cream cheese mints are richer and smoother because of the dairy base. Buttermints are drier but still flavorful, with a more powdery finish.

In terms of use, both work well for weddings, showers, and holidays. However, cream cheese-based mints have a softer bite, making them ideal for events where texture matters, like baby showers or afternoon teas.

Want a fun pairing on your dessert table? Serve your mints alongside banana pudding dip or some blueberry sour cream scones for a mix of creamy, fruity, and minty.

No-Gum-Paste Mint Making Tips

Gum Paste Substitutes for Mints

You don’t need gum paste to make smooth, delicious cream cheese mints. In fact, traditional recipes never call for it. The texture comes from the cream cheese and powdered sugar blend, which firms up beautifully as it dries.

If you’re looking for a firmer bite without using gum paste, try adding a small amount of cornstarch or extra sugar during the mixing stage. This helps the mints hold their shape better and speeds up the drying process.

Looking for another easy treat that skips specialty ingredients? These no-bake peanut butter cookies are simple and require no oven or candy molds.

Easy No-Gum-Paste Mint Recipes

Some candy makers use fondant or marshmallow base, but the easiest alternative is the classic cream cheese mints recipe. It’s quick, cost-effective, and doesn’t rely on hard-to-find ingredients.

To create fun shapes without gum paste tools, use silicone molds, mini cookie cutters, or even your fingers to flatten and score small discs. Chill them before handling for easier shaping.

Hosting a casual event? Pair your homemade mints with easy comfort foods like this creamy hamburger rice casserole or fruity pineapple coconut chess bars.

Softening Cream Cheese the Right Way

How Long to Leave Cream Cheese Out

Getting the right texture for cream cheese mints starts with properly softened cream cheese. If it’s too cold, the mixture won’t blend well. Too warm, and it turns greasy. The sweet spot? Let your cream cheese sit at room temperature for about 30 to 60 minutes.

To speed up the process, cut the block into cubes and spread them out on a plate. Avoid microwaving—it causes uneven softening and can ruin the texture. Once softened, mix it with peppermint extract before adding sugar gradually.

Making brunch alongside candy? These quiche with hash brown crust pair beautifully with mints for a full spread of sweet and savory.

Safe Softening Tips and Tricks

Food safety matters. Never leave cream cheese out for more than 2 hours. If your kitchen is warm, use a bowl of warm water under your cream cheese bowl to gently raise the temperature without melting.

Check the consistency by pressing a spoon into it—if it gives easily but doesn’t collapse, it’s ready. This step ensures your cream cheese mints have the perfect balance of creaminess and structure.

Once mixed, chill your dough for 15 minutes before shaping for easier handling. Need more prep-ahead dishes? This flavorful garlic confit can be made days in advance and works great as a savory counter to your sweet mints.

Troubleshooting Common Cream Cheese Mint Issues

Why Mints May Crack, Melt, or Stay Sticky

Even if you follow the recipe, cream cheese mints can sometimes crack, melt, or remain sticky. Cracking usually happens when the dough is too dry. This may come from using too much powdered sugar or working in a dry environment. To fix it, knead in a teaspoon of softened cream cheese until the texture smooths out.

If your mints melt or feel overly soft, it’s likely due to excess moisture or poor drying. Avoid covering them during the drying process. Let them rest uncovered for at least 12 hours.

Sticky mints often mean they didn’t dry long enough or the sugar wasn’t fully incorporated. Next time, sift the sugar and mix longer.

Looking for a treat that holds shape no matter what? Try this key lime pound cake—zesty, dense, and built to impress.

How to Fix Texture or Flavor Mistakes

Don’t toss your batch just yet—most cream cheese mints can be saved. If your mix is too sweet, add a pinch of salt or a few drops of citrus extract to balance the flavor. If the mint flavor is too weak, re-knead with a small amount of extract—just go slow to avoid overpowering.

For texture issues, chilling helps firm things up quickly. Soft, sticky dough? Wrap it in plastic and refrigerate for 30 minutes before shaping.

Need more no-fail sweets? These rich elephant ears are quick to prep and deliver that perfect balance of crisp and sweet every time.

FAQ About Cream Cheese Mints

Conclusion: Cream Cheese Mints – Sweet, Simple, and Always a Hit

Cream cheese mints are one of the easiest and most rewarding treats to make at home. With just a few ingredients, you can create soft, flavorful mints that suit any occasion—from casual gatherings to elegant weddings. Whether you prefer classic peppermint or unique flavor blends, the process remains simple and flexible.

By understanding the ingredients, proper softening methods, drying techniques, and storage, you’ll avoid common issues like cracking or stickiness. Best of all, you can make large batches in advance and present them beautifully.

For more party-ready sweets and comfort bakes, explore our latest dessert recipes and crowd-pleasing ideas on What to Make Today.

For more creative baking inspiration and marketing ideas, explore the Facebook and Pinterest.

whattomaketoday.com.

Print